GM. This is Dumb Money - the only financial newsletter with a 100% loss rate.
Oil hit $108 a barrel this week. Bitcoin dropped below $77,000. The S&P 500 had its worst four-day stretch since June.
And three people on the internet managed to make all of it worse for themselves personally.
Here's what we've got today:
🏆 Loss of the Day - A Brent crude short into an active war zone. Margin called in 8 days.: $70,000
📉 Casualty #1 - Selling puts on a stock "already down 52%." It went down more.: $27,050
✈️ Casualty #2 - An all-in airline bet right before oil hit $100. Timing is everything.: $24,438
📊 Today by the Numbers - The data on today's carnage. It is worse than you think.
| |||||||||
| TODAY'S DAMAGE REPORT 📊 | |||||||||
| |||||||||
|
While the world panicked, these investors got paid
Since Feb 28th, the S&P has slid -4.1%.
But the people invested in the Patriot Income Plan (P.I.P.)...
They barely noticed.
While the world panicked over "World War III"
Their distributions kept arriving. On schedule. In full. Some have collected 15+ separate payouts during the three months of war.
And their portfolios? The average partnership inside P.I.P. has gained 7.2% during this conflict. The best performer rose 15.3%.
That's the difference between owning stocks and owning infrastructure.
Stocks trade on fear. Infrastructure collects fees on every molecule of oil and gas that moves through America, war or peace, boom or bust.
And that's exactly what P.I.P. is.
A way for you to own critical infrastructure that pays you whether America is at war or not.
With unit prices cooling from wartime highs, today may be the best entry point in months. The next P.I.P. payout is days away.
P.S. Since 2020, the average partnership in P.I.P. has produced 20% avg. annual gains. That's in addition to the 10% yield. One investor already collects $4,800 a month. Another hasn't worked in years. Show me something better. I'll wait. [Enroll in P.I.P. →]
LOSS OF THE DAY 🏆
Every day we crown one person who made the worst financial decision on the internet.
Today's winner shorted oil during a war. Not a metaphorical war. An actual war with missiles.
Here's the setup. A trader on r/commodities saw Brent crude at $93 a barrel on September 2. His thesis: summer driving season ending, demand fading, war premium "overblown."
He posted a three-paragraph breakdown. Zero mention of Iran. Zero mention of the Strait of Hormuz. Zero mention of the Saudi refinery attacks that were already in the news.
He shorted 5 Brent crude contracts at $93.
Over the next eight days, the U.S. struck Iranian oil tankers. Iran launched missiles at U.S. warships. The Houthis hit Saudi refineries. Oil went from $93 to $108.
He was margin called at $107. Total loss: $70,000.
His post title: "Oil is mean-reverting. I was early."
| |||||
| |||||
| |||||
|
| ||||||
| Quick math on oil futures for non-commodity people: Each Brent crude contract controls 1,000 barrels. At $93 per barrel, that's $93,000 of notional exposure per contract. Initial margin is roughly $8,000 per contract. A $14 move on 5 contracts wipes out your entire $40,000 margin deposit and then some. |
Brother. You weren't early. You were short oil during a shooting war in the world's most important shipping lane. There is no mean reversion for missiles.
| 💀 |
TODAY'S CASUALTIES 💀
Not everybody can be Loss of the Day. But these two gave it a real shot.
Let's run through the tape.
Casualty #1: The "Free Money" Put Seller
There's a phrase that echoes through every options forum right before someone gets assigned. That phrase is "selling puts is free money."
Here's what u/theta_gang_rise_up did. He sold 50 put contracts on The Trade Desk at a $22 strike in late July. The stock was already down 52% on the year.
His thesis: the bottom was in. He collected $3.20 per share in premium. $16,000 in instant income.
One problem: The Trade Desk reported Q2 earnings on August 6. Revenue missed. Guidance missed. The stock dropped 24% after hours to $13.39.
His 50 puts were assigned. He now owned 5,000 shares of TTD at $22 each on a $13.39 stock.
Net loss after premium: $27,050.
| |||||
| |||||
| |||||
|
| ||||||
| Quick explainer on selling puts: When you sell a put, you promise to buy a stock at the strike price if it falls below that level. You collect premium upfront, which feels like income. But if the stock craters, you buy at your strike price even though the stock is trading far below it. The premium never covers the gap. |
He posted the assignment notice with the caption above. The irony is that theta gang's entire philosophy is about collecting small, consistent premiums. Not about waking up to a $27,050 hole.
| 🎰 |
Casualty #2: The Summer Travel Thesis
This one hurts because the thesis actually made sense. On paper.
u/blue_sky_portfolio read every airline analyst report in August. Strong summer bookings. Record passenger numbers. 23 of 25 analysts rated UAL a Buy with a $161 price target.
He put $136,000 into United Airlines at $128 per share. His entire taxable brokerage account. One thing he didn't factor in: jet fuel.
Brent crude went from $93 to $108 in eight days. Jet fuel costs surged to nearly $180 per barrel. United Airlines is completely unhedged against fuel prices.
UAL dropped from $128 to $105. His $136,000 is now worth $111,562.
Unrealized loss: $24,438.
| |||||
| |||||
| |||||
|
Here's the thing. The travel demand thesis was correct. Summer bookings were at record levels. But fuel costs eat 25% of an airline's operating expenses. When oil spikes 16% in a week, the math changes whether you read the analyst report or not.
The analyst target is still $161. The stock does not care about the analyst target.
| ⚡ |
TODAY BY THE NUMBERS 📊
We track the data because the data is funnier than anything we could make up.
|
| ||
|
|
The correlation between analyst consensus and portfolio destruction remains underexplored.
We've been tracking it all year. Every time 20+ analysts agree on a rating, the average retail trader who follows it is down 14% within 60 days. Not because the analysts are wrong. Because retail traders don't read past the price target.
See you tomorrow. The numbers will be different. The behavior won't be.
| 🍪 |


